What Needs to Change
The consequences for editors of being invisible.
By Karen Yin • March 15, 2016
With editorial styles continuously evolving to reflect shifts in needs, sensibilities, technologies, and markets, it is just as important to notice what hasn’t changed. What stood out for me after reviewing 25 years of style changes is that, as a whole, we copyeditors resist changing our own style of thinking about our profession. Specifically, we’ve held on to a core, almost sacred, belief that editors must be invisible.
This attitude—that we must toil in the shadows—served copyeditors in the past yet cries for reappraisal in these unusual times. We pride ourselves on letting the writer have the spotlight, yet we wonder why our profession has lost relevance. We wonder why readers, who are also potential clients or employers, are oblivious to our impact behind the scenes and don’t recognize our value.
Editing itself should be invisible—copyeditors can no longer afford to be.
Many copyeditors still find the notion of public acknowledgment distasteful, but the consequences of being invisible have been felt throughout the industry. For the sake of not being judged as ostentatious, we—the gatekeepers and content shapers—have lost our footing in trying to preserve a romantic ideal that has failed us. How long can we eke out a living on an old model of professionalism when media itself has changed in drastic, fundamental ways?
We are charged with nipping libel suits, stereotypes, off-brand language, and plain ol’ BS in the bud. To do our jobs, we become historians, quality controllers, trend experts, ghost writers, and diplomats. Each assertion and correction is an act of bravery. But I don’t want a medal or token gesture; I want to educate people on why copyeditors are a reader’s and writer’s strongest allies and to revitalize this beleaguered profession. A perpetual byline strike protests nothing, and continued anonymity is suicide. Editing itself should be invisible—copyeditors can no longer afford to be.
Karen Yin is the founder of Conscious Style Guide, a resource for inclusive, empowering, and respectful language, and AP vs. Chicago, an irreverent language blog for anyone who “gives a dollar sign, ampersand, exclamation point, and pound sign about style.” Winner of the Robinson Prize in 2017 for furthering the craft of professional editing, Karen was a columnist for Copyediting and the keynote speaker at the Northwest Independent Editors Guild's Red Pencil 6 conference.